I did not include Utah, TCU and Louisville because their hires either happened pre P5 or the year before the hire they were not P5. This was the last hires schools made for the 2018 or before. So for example CU would be MacIntyre. BTW when I said made a bowl I mean they have 6 regular season or more wins, some had post season bans and Notre Dame at 6-6 decided not to go to a bowl.
So of the 62 P5 school
33 made bowls their first full seasons.
29 did not
Of the 33 that made bowls, 23 schools made bowls the previous year before the hire, 10 did not
Of the 29 that did not make a bowl, 10 made bowls the previous year before the hire, 19 did not
Coach-School-Bowl/no bowl-year hired-bowl/no bowl the year before hire
Saban-Alabama-Bowl-2007-Bowl
Edwards-Arizona-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Sumlin-Arizona State-No Bowl-2018-Bowl
Morris-Arkansas-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Malzahn-Auburn-Bowl-2013-No Bowl
Rhule-Baylor-No Bowl-2017-Bowl
Adazzio-Boston College-Bowl -2013-No Bowl
Wilcox -California-No Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Swinney-Clemson-Bowl-2008-Bowl
MacIntyre-Colorado-No Bowl-2013-No Bowl
Cutcliff-Duke-No Bowl-2008-No Bowl
Mullen-Florida-Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Tagget-Florida State-No Bowl -2018-Bowl
Smart-Georgia-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Johnson-Georgia Tech-Bowl-2008-Bowl
Smith-Illinois-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Allen-Indiana-No Bowl-2017-Bowl
Ferentz-Iowa-No Bowl-1999-No Bowl
Campbell-Iowa State-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Beaty-Kansas-No Bowl-2015-No Bowl
Snyder-Kansas State-No Bowl-2009-No Bowl
Stoops-Kentucky-No Bowl-2013-No Bowl
Orgeron-LSU-Bowl-2017-Bowl
Durkin-Maryland-Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Richt-Miami-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Harbaugh-Michigan-Bowl-2015-No Bowl
Dantonio-Michigan State-Bowl-2007-No Bowl
Fleck-Minnesota-No Bowl-2017-Bowl
Luke-Mississippi-Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Moorhead-Mississippi State-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Odom-Missouri-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Frost-Nebraska-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Fedora-North Carolina-Bowl-2012-Bowl
Doeren-North Carolina State-No Bowl-2013-Bowl
Fitzgerald-Northwestern-No Bowl-2006-Bowl
Kelly-Notre Dame-Bowl-2010-Bowl
Meyer-Ohio State-Bowl-2012-Bowl
Riley-Oklahoma-Bowl-2017-Bowl
Gundy-Oklahoma State-No Bowl-2005-Bowl
Cristobal-Oregon-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Smith-Oregon State-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Franklin-Penn State-Bowl-2014-Bowl
Narduzzi-Pittsburgh-Bowl-2015-Bowl
Brohm-Purdue-Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Ash-Rutgers-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Muschamp-South Carolina-Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Shaw-Stanford-Bowl-2011-Bowl
Babers-Syracuse-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Pruitt-Tennessee-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Herman-Texas-Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Fisher-Texas A&M-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Kingsbury -Texas Tech-Bowl-2013-Bowl
Kelly-UCLA-No Bowl-2018-Bowl
Helton-USC-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Mason-Vanderbilt-No Bowl-2014-Bowl
Mendenhall-Virginia-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Fuente-Virginia Tech-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Clawson-Wake Forest-No Bowl-2014-No Bowl
Petersen-Washington-Bowl-2014-Bowl
Leach-Washington State-No Bowl-2012-No Bowl
Holgorsen-West Virginia-Bowl-2011-Bowl
Chryst-Wisconsin-Bowl-2015-Bowl
So of the 62 P5 school
33 made bowls their first full seasons.
29 did not
Of the 33 that made bowls, 23 schools made bowls the previous year before the hire, 10 did not
Of the 29 that did not make a bowl, 10 made bowls the previous year before the hire, 19 did not
Coach-School-Bowl/no bowl-year hired-bowl/no bowl the year before hire
Saban-Alabama-Bowl-2007-Bowl
Edwards-Arizona-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Sumlin-Arizona State-No Bowl-2018-Bowl
Morris-Arkansas-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Malzahn-Auburn-Bowl-2013-No Bowl
Rhule-Baylor-No Bowl-2017-Bowl
Adazzio-Boston College-Bowl -2013-No Bowl
Wilcox -California-No Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Swinney-Clemson-Bowl-2008-Bowl
MacIntyre-Colorado-No Bowl-2013-No Bowl
Cutcliff-Duke-No Bowl-2008-No Bowl
Mullen-Florida-Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Tagget-Florida State-No Bowl -2018-Bowl
Smart-Georgia-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Johnson-Georgia Tech-Bowl-2008-Bowl
Smith-Illinois-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Allen-Indiana-No Bowl-2017-Bowl
Ferentz-Iowa-No Bowl-1999-No Bowl
Campbell-Iowa State-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Beaty-Kansas-No Bowl-2015-No Bowl
Snyder-Kansas State-No Bowl-2009-No Bowl
Stoops-Kentucky-No Bowl-2013-No Bowl
Orgeron-LSU-Bowl-2017-Bowl
Durkin-Maryland-Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Richt-Miami-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Harbaugh-Michigan-Bowl-2015-No Bowl
Dantonio-Michigan State-Bowl-2007-No Bowl
Fleck-Minnesota-No Bowl-2017-Bowl
Luke-Mississippi-Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Moorhead-Mississippi State-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Odom-Missouri-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Frost-Nebraska-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Fedora-North Carolina-Bowl-2012-Bowl
Doeren-North Carolina State-No Bowl-2013-Bowl
Fitzgerald-Northwestern-No Bowl-2006-Bowl
Kelly-Notre Dame-Bowl-2010-Bowl
Meyer-Ohio State-Bowl-2012-Bowl
Riley-Oklahoma-Bowl-2017-Bowl
Gundy-Oklahoma State-No Bowl-2005-Bowl
Cristobal-Oregon-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Smith-Oregon State-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Franklin-Penn State-Bowl-2014-Bowl
Narduzzi-Pittsburgh-Bowl-2015-Bowl
Brohm-Purdue-Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Ash-Rutgers-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Muschamp-South Carolina-Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Shaw-Stanford-Bowl-2011-Bowl
Babers-Syracuse-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Pruitt-Tennessee-No Bowl-2018-No Bowl
Herman-Texas-Bowl-2017-No Bowl
Fisher-Texas A&M-Bowl-2018-Bowl
Kingsbury -Texas Tech-Bowl-2013-Bowl
Kelly-UCLA-No Bowl-2018-Bowl
Helton-USC-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Mason-Vanderbilt-No Bowl-2014-Bowl
Mendenhall-Virginia-No Bowl-2016-No Bowl
Fuente-Virginia Tech-Bowl-2016-Bowl
Clawson-Wake Forest-No Bowl-2014-No Bowl
Petersen-Washington-Bowl-2014-Bowl
Leach-Washington State-No Bowl-2012-No Bowl
Holgorsen-West Virginia-Bowl-2011-Bowl
Chryst-Wisconsin-Bowl-2015-Bowl